For many successful business owners and families, philanthropy becomes a focus following a significant wealth event. Whether it is the sale of a business or a desire to create a lasting family legacy, a common question is how to give back in a structured and meaningful way.
One option increasingly used by high-net-worth individuals, families and family offices, is a Private Ancillary Fund (PAF). Their popularity has grown significantly in recent years. In 2023-24, it is reported that Australian PAFs distributed more than $914 million, representing an annual increase of approximately $414 million since 2020-21. These figures reflect the growing role PAFs play in Australia’s philanthropic landscape and their appeal as a structured long-term giving vehicle.
PAFs have tax planning advantages, primarily being that a PAF allows founders to claim up front income tax deductions at the time funds are contributed to a PAF, but before those funds are committed to eligible recipients. This contrasts with ordinary charitable donations, which are claimed in the year the contributions are made to eligible charities. PAFs also allow for the growth of the corpus of a charitable fund inside a tax-exempt vehicle.
What is a Private Ancillary Fund?
A PAF is a type of private charitable trust established for the sole purpose of distributing funds to eligible deductible gift recipients (DGRs). Unlike an ordinary charity that undertakes charitable activities in furtherance of its charitable purpose, a PAF does not ‘do’ anything charitable. It can only distribute funds to DGRs in compliance with its trust deed.
It is established by a contribution (usually an upfront lump sum) made by an individual or family. The directors of its corporate trustee must invest those funds and make annual distributions to other eligible DGRs.
PAFs are particularly popular following a liquidity event, such as the sale of a business. Rather than making a one-off donation to a DGR:
- an individual can contribute capital to a tax-exempt charitable structure;
- provided the PAF is also endorsed as a DGR obtain a deduction up front (or spread over up to five years as deductions from gifts cannot give rise to carried forward losses); and
- the PAF can invest the contributions over the long term whilst retaining control over to whom charitable distributions are made.
Why families and family offices use Private Ancillary Funds
The ability to separate the timing of the tax deduction from the timing of charitable distributions is one of the key attractions of a PAF. In addition, both donated capital and investment earnings can accumulate within the PAF free from income tax. This enables families to build the capital of charitable funds and adopt a more strategic and flexible approach to philanthropic activities across multiple generations.
A PAF therefore offers advantages over making annual donations directly to charities, which are deductible only in the year they are made, and do not allow a donor to build philanthropic capital within a tax exempt environment for strategic giving over time.
PAFs are also used to involve successive generations of a family in charitable giving and philanthropic decision-making, creating a legacy for its founders. Children and grandchildren may participate in trustee meetings, discuss charitable priorities and help decide which causes or organisations receive support. In this way, a PAF can become part of a family’s culture and values, both now and across generations.
Despite these advantages, a PAF involves ongoing responsibilities and is not appropriate in every case.
Trustee duties and governance requirements
While a PAF offers flexibility and control, it is not a passive structure. A PAF must have a corporate trustee, and at least one director of the corporate trustee must be a “responsible person”. A responsible person may be lawyer, accountant or medical professional, but there are also strict restrictions.
The directors of the corporate trustee are ultimately responsible for ensuring that the PAF complies with its ongoing governance, reporting and operational obligations. A key aspect of that responsibility is maintaining an appropriate investment strategy for the fund.
The investment strategy should address matters such as investment risk, diversification, liquidity, conflicts of interest and the fund’s future distribution requirements. In practical terms, the fund should be invested prudently, with sufficient liquidity to meet its charitable commitments while preserving capital over the longer term.
In addition to overseeing the investment strategy, the directors must ensure that the PAF satisfies its ongoing compliance obligations. These include arranging an annual audit of the fund’s financial statements and meeting the minimum annual distribution requirement. Currently, a PAF must distribute at least 5% of the value of its net assets each year to eligible DGRs.
Donors should also be aware that contributions to a PAF are irrevocably committed to charitable purposes. Funds contributed to a PAF cannot be returned to the donor or their family members. If the PAF is wound up, any remaining assets must be transferred to another eligible DGR.
Proposed reforms to Private Ancillary Funds
The Federal Government has announced proposed reforms that would:
- rename PAFs to ‘Private Giving Funds’;
- increase the minimum annual distribution requirement from 5% to 6%; and
- introduce a three-year averaging mechanism to provide greater flexibility around annual distributions to allow a PAF to provide support to a large charitable project without making excessive draw downs on its capital.
Of particular significance to PAFs are the proposed trust tax reforms, for which exposure draft legislation has recently been released. The exposure draft excludes qualifying distributions to registered charities and other DGRs from the proposed 30% minimum trust tax. As a result, distributions from discretionary trusts to a PAF or other DGR should not be subject to the minimum tax before reaching the recipient DGR.
The exclusion will apply only where the relevant distribution satisfies the legislative requirements and any additional conditions prescribed by the Minister by legislative instrument, which may impose further eligibility, substantiation or compliance obligations. Although there remains an unfortunate lack of clarity, we expect PAFs to continue to be a popular and effective structure for charitable giving. For families pursuing a long-term philanthropic strategy, a PAF provides a flexible framework for making distributions over time.
Establishing and running a PAF involves a range of tax, trust, governance and succession considerations. McCullough Robertson’s Private team advises business owners, families and family offices on the establishment and administration of PAFs and other philanthropic structures, helping clients integrate charitable giving into their broader wealth and legacy planning.